Why increasing guest frequency and spending starts with giving people a reason to return
By Jamie Galler | Restaurant Advisor
The night before last, I stopped at a very busy restaurant and managed to find one of the few open seats at the bar. The place was jammed. The bartenders were moving nonstop, and I knew I might have to wait.
But one bartender caught my eye, smiled and said, “How are you? I’ll be with you in just a few.” When she had a moment to serve me, she thanked me for waiting.
It was a small gesture. It also made a big impression. I wasn’t ignored, and I wasn’t made to feel like an inconvenience. She acknowledged me, set an expectation and followed through.
That’s hospitality. And it is one of the many reasons people decide whether to come back.
The Sale That Matters After Today
Most restaurant operators know the basic equation:
Sales = Number of Covers × Average Check
But there is another useful way to look at covers: the number of customers you attract multiplied by how often they visit. That gives us three levers for growth: attract new customers, increase the frequency of existing customers, and increase the amount guests spend per visit.
Too often, restaurants focus on the first lever. They advertise, promote, post on social media and offer incentives to bring new people through the door. Those activities can matter. But what happens after the first visit?
Suppose 500 customers currently visit your restaurant once a month and spend $40 each. That represents $20,000 in monthly sales. If those same customers begin visiting twice a month, the revenue becomes $40,000, before considering any change in average check. It is an illustration, not a forecast, but it makes the opportunity clear.
The most important sale may not be the one you make today. It may be the one you earn when the guest chooses to return.
There’s No Single Secret to Creating Regulars
After years of operating restaurants, I’ve learned that no single gesture turns an occasional guest into a loyal regular. It’s the accumulation of experiences, often small ones, that tells someone, “I like coming here.”
It starts with a warm, genuine greeting. Remembering a name. Recognizing a familiar face. Thanking guests sincerely for choosing your restaurant. Saying goodbye as if you hope to see them again, because you do.
It also means providing attentive service rather than simply taking orders. A good server or bartender offers thoughtful suggestions based on what the guest might enjoy. That can improve the experience and the average check without making the interaction feel like a sales pitch.
Managers have a role, too. Read the room. Notice the table that keeps looking toward the kitchen, the guests who are becoming restless, or the entrée with most of the food still on the plate. Don’t wait for a complaint before asking whether everything is all right, and when you do ask, be specific.
And never confuse value with the lowest price. Value is the total experience: food, service, consistency, atmosphere, convenience and how people feel while they are with you.
Every guest chose to spend hard-earned money in your restaurant instead of somewhere else. That choice deserves appreciation.
Challenge Your Staff to Create Regulars
One of the best ways to make guest loyalty part of the culture is to involve the whole team. Challenge employees to get to know guests, recognize returning faces and help turn first-time visitors into regulars. It can be fun, and it gives everyone a role in growing the business.
When I was a TGI Fridays franchisee, our policy was to card everyone at the bar, regardless of age. That created an easy opening for conversation. Bartenders could learn a guest’s name and what state they lived in, then naturally ask a question: “You’re from New York? I’m going there next month. What brings you here?”
Maybe the guest was visiting family, had recently moved nearby or was in town for work. A routine interaction became a personal one. On a later visit, remembering that detail could make the guest feel at home.
This wasn’t about interrogating customers or forcing familiarity. It was about being curious, friendly and attentive. Employees can learn to recognize when someone wants to chat and when someone would rather be left alone.
Encourage your team to share stories of guests they have gotten to know. Recognize employees who remember preferences, make a thoughtful introduction or welcome a returning customer by name. Make “Who did we give a reason to return today?” a question worth asking at pre-shift or after service.
Listen to What Guests Are Telling You
Customer feedback is not limited to online reviews or formal complaints. Guests communicate constantly, sometimes without saying a word.
A nearly untouched meal, a delayed drink, an impatient glance or a guest who stops visiting can all be signals. The operator’s job is to notice patterns and act before a small disappointment becomes a lost customer.
When someone does raise a concern, listen without defensiveness, fix what you can and thank them for bringing it to your attention. A well-handled problem can preserve a relationship. An ignored problem can end one.
The most troubling guest may be the one who never complains, pays the check and simply never returns.
Are Your Discounts Building Loyalty or Giving Away Margin?
Discounts have a place, but they should have a purpose. A promotion that brings in an incremental visit may be worthwhile. A blanket discount given to someone who would have visited and paid full price may simply reduce profit.
Ask whether your offers are changing behavior. Are guests returning sooner? Visiting more often? Trying something new? Spending more over time? Or are they only responding when the price is reduced?
A loyal guest should be loyal to the experience, not just the coupon. Recognition, consistency and genuine hospitality can create value that a discount can’t.
Measure Frequency and Spend
If increasing repeat business is a priority, make it measurable. Your POS, reservation system, loyalty program or online ordering platform may already contain useful information, although not every system can reliably identify every guest.
Start with a few practical measures:
· Repeat-visit rate: What share of identifiable guests return?
· Visit frequency: How often do returning guests come back?
· Average check: What does each visit generate in sales?
· Time between visits: Is the interval getting shorter or longer?
· Guest feedback: What recurring issues could discourage a return?
Use the information to identify trends, test changes and coach your team. Avoid collecting data merely because the system can produce another report. The objective is to improve the guest experience and the business results that follow.
The Operator Challenge
This week, spend 30 minutes observing your restaurant through the eyes of a guest. Are people acknowledged promptly, even when the staff is busy? Do employees make useful suggestions? Are managers reading the room? Do guests receive a genuine thank-you and goodbye?
Then ask your team to do one thing: make a personal connection with someone they have not met before, and give that person a reason to return. Share what happens. Repeat it until it becomes part of the culture.
Finally, look at the numbers. Do you know how frequently your guests return and what they spend? If not, identify what your current systems can tell you and begin there.
Don’t just ask how many customers you served today. Ask how many you gave a reason to come back.
Because the most important sale is the next visit.
Jamie Galler
Restaurant Advisor | Former Multi-Unit Restaurant Operator
The Practical Creative
Practical Solutions. Creative Approaches. Measurable Outcomes.
Helping independent restaurants and restaurant groups increase profitability, grow sales, build better operations and develop stronger leaders.
Want a clearer view of the numbers driving your restaurant’s profitability?
The Practical Creative helps restaurant operators build practical measurement systems, identify performance gaps and turn operating data into measurable financial results. Schedule a complimentary discovery meeting at thepracticalcreative.com.